Original Language: English

Títutulu Original: John Jago’s Ghost

Translation: Miguel Ángel Herranz

Year of publication: 1874

Valoración: Expendable

A London lawyer takes a time to rest in the farm of a relative of his mother who lives in the United States. Although Our protagonist yearns Peace and tranquility far from their demanding profession, do not find them at all. On the contrary: he discovers that their hosts do not get along well and witness a disappearance that public opinion does not take to warn murder.

This is the premise of John Jago’s ghostshort novel of about one hundred pages. Its author, Wilkie Collins, was extremely skilled, so it is correctly written. However, it gives the feeling that it was elaborated in a somewhat routine way (perhaps it is too attached to the real events on which it is based), and lacks the spark of other works by Collins. Therefore, it is not only less than classics such as The Blanco Lady o The lunar stonebut it also falls short when comparing it with minor proposals as entertaining and solvent as The Enchanted Hotel.

I already say that John Jago’s ghost It is correctly written. Unfortunately, it is a novel insula because of its linear argument, its stubborn characters, its missed atmosphere and its merely functional prose.

Some of his sections would shine a bit if he had put more care in them. For example, the main cast of the work could be enriched with nuances if it will not be in a purely dichotomous framework, in which there are only good or petty people. Likewise, the plot would arouse more interest if it were not so simple and obvious, and if the few revelations that splashed it, such as the one that John makes Naomi, Suvbirt the reader’s expectations, instead of reaffirming them.

I inevitably compared John Jago’s ghost con The beast in the shadowsby Edogawa Rampo. Both are short novels with touches of mystery and romance in which a male protagonist tries to help a woman who has fallen in love. However, in the Japanese work intrigue and tension are much more achieved, the atmosphere is better embodied, the revelations are unexpected and rewarding instead of predictable, the argument is very complex, the protagonist has a real participation in the story and all the characters present clear.
Also from Wilkie Collins in Ulad: Here

Source: https://unlibroaldia.blogspot.com/2025/07/wilkie-collins-el-fantasma-de-john-jago.html



Leave a Reply